| |
At the Top of the
Class Newsweek, by Pat Wingert and Barbara Kantrowitz (March
24, 2003)
Adalberto Garza's 13-year- old son, Adalberto Jr.,
was tagged a problem learner in his Houston elementary school. He's
dyslexic and, because his first language is Spanish,
English-speaking teachers often had difficulty understanding him.
"His accent and his way of talking made him seem as if he had a
mental handicap," his father says. But after Adalberto Jr. enrolled
at KIPP Academy Houston, his grades shot up. At KIPP, Garza says,
the teachers "are truly interested in our children."
Garza is not the only one
who's impressed. Many education reformers think the Houston middle
school and 14 other KIPP schools in 11 states and the District of
Columbia may have found a better way to educate disadvantaged
students. And KIPP has also become a national model for more
widespread reform of charter-school programs. KIPP began in the
mid-1990s, when Michael Feinberg and David Levin, two alums of Teach
for America (which sends recent college graduates into urban
schools), grew frustrated by their lack of progress teaching fifth
graders in the Houston Independent School District. They persuaded
the then Superintendent Rod Paige (now the secretary of Education)
to let them try a new concept--demanding academics, much longer days
and stricter discipline. Feinberg and Levin called their class the
Knowledge Is Power Program, and their results were striking: 98
percent of their students passed the state's standardized tests
compared with just 50 percent the year before. Feinberg went on to
open the Houston school, and Levin started a second KIPP school in
the Bronx. At both, students attend class 10 hours a day plus
alternate Saturdays as well as summers. Teachers carry cell phones
so they can be reached 24/7 if students need help (they get a
stipend for the extra hours). And students sign a pledge to abide by
the rules.
Although middle schools are
notoriously difficult to run, KIPP students were soon outscoring
their peers in other schools and winning national attention,
including an appearance at the 2000 GOP convention. Results like
these attracted more districts and foundation money, including $25
million in the past few years from the Pisces Foundation (started by
the founders of the Gap chain) to help open more KIPP schools. It's
too soon to say how the newer schools will do in the long run, but a
KIPP-commissioned study last fall indicated that the first three
spinoffs outperformed their districts.
Education reformers say
KIPP represents the second wave of charter schools, public schools
that design their own curricula. States have had mixed results with
charters. Despite high hopes, scores at many charters are no better
than regular public schools. And while some reformers argue that
charters are primarily about choice, others say that the point was
to make demonstrably better schools--not just different ones. They
contend that there simply aren't enough successful charters and want
to focus on creating prototypes that really work and can be
replicated.
KIPP is aiming to be among
the best of these prototypes. The plan is to double the network next
year by opening 19 more schools. All the schools will be in poor
communities. The real challenge, the founders say, will be to let
the principals decide the best way to operate in their particular
locations while still embracing the basic KIPP philosophy. Quality
control will be a big issue; KIPP's founders, both still at their
original schools, say they will hire a team of inspectors to monitor
progress at the new schools. One problem they don't have is
attracting students and teachers--despite the rigorous schedule. At
the KIPP DC Key Academy, which opened in 2001, principal Susan
Schaeffler already has a waiting list for students. And last year
she received 250 applicants for four teacher openings despite a
national urban teacher shortage. But the best indicators of success
are the students themselves. During one recent class, Diamond
Branch, 11, in her second year at the school, let out an
enthusiastic "Yes" when her teacher returned a quiz. "I was excited
to see my grade," she says. "I just want to keep those A's and B's
rolling."
|
|